What to Do With Duplicate Christmas Gifts

Exchange duplicates for credit, regift with care, or donate extras before return windows close.
If you receive duplicate Christmas gifts, exchange one with a gift receipt, return it for store credit, regift it thoughtfully, or donate it. A duplicate gift means you received two usable copies of the same item, often from different givers. Start with the store receipt or order details, then check the return deadline.
Acting in the first week after Christmas keeps more options open and avoids missing a cutoff.
Verification note: Program terms and availability can change. This page was checked against linked sources on November 16, 2026.
Can you exchange it where it was bought?
Ask the giver politely whether they included a gift receipt. Target notes that recipients holding duplicate gifts can use a gift receipt or packing-slip order number to seek an exchange or store credit instead of keeping a second copy, as explained in Target returns. Keep tags, packaging, and any packing slip until the exchange is done.
Many stores will not refund the giver's payment method to you, so expect store credit.
- Save the gift receipt, box, and tags
- Ask which store the item came from
- Request exchange or store credit, not cash
How do Amazon gift returns work?
Amazon tells gift recipients with the same item already or the wrong size to use its Returns Center, with refunds to recipients generally issued as Amazon.com gift-card balance to the account that created the return, according to Amazon gift return. Timing matters for holiday duplicates. Amazon's extended holiday window lets most items shipped Nov.
1-Dec. 31 be returned through Jan. 31, while Apple-branded holiday items have an earlier Jan.
15 deadline, as described in the holiday returns guide. Start the return soon after Christmas so the extra copy does not miss its date.
When is it okay to regift?
Regifting works best when the duplicate is still brand new and fits the next person. The Emily Post Institute permits regifting duplicates only when the item is brand new with original packaging and instructions, suits the new recipient, and is not handmade, personalized, or carefully chosen by the original giver, as explained in regifting tips. Do not rewrap a used, opened, or personalized item.
A new candle set, unopened game, or extra kitchen tool suits a friend who would use it.
- Keep it sealed with parts and instructions
- Match it to someone who wants it
- Skip handmade or engraved gifts
Should you donate or keep the extra?
Keep the duplicate only if a second copy helps, such as school supplies, socks, or kitchen basics for another room. Two identical toys with no return option often create clutter rather than extra play value. Donate a clean, unreturnable duplicate to a local charity, shelter drive, school, or food pantry toy collection.
Place the sealed item in your donation bag now so it reaches someone who can use it this winter.