Thanksgiving Pie Deals: Free Pie Day Explained
Free pie is available weekly with a meal or Nov. 24 by reservation — check dine-in, purchase, and pickup rules first.
There is no single national Free Pie Day for Thanksgiving. The phrase covers separate pie offers that happen around the holiday. Some give a free slice with a restaurant meal each week.
Others give a free whole pie at a one-day local pickup with advance sign-up.
Verification note: Program terms and availability can change. This page was checked against linked sources on November 05, 2026.
What does Free Pie Day mean?
Free Pie Day is a shorthand readers use for different free-pie deals. It does not refer to one holiday with one sponsor and one rule. That matters because each offer has its own date, place, and limit.
A weekly restaurant slice and a one-day pickup pie work in different ways.
How does Free Pie Wednesday work?
Bakers Square says its Free Pie Wednesday runs every Wednesday. Dine-in guests receive one free slice with an entrée and beverage purchase from 10:30 a.m. until close, according to the Bakers Square promotion page.
The Schererville location terms state the slice is dine-in only and limited to one per person per visit. Specialty desserts, Pie Shop Special, and Bakers Bundle are excluded, and only participating locations honor it, according to the Schererville location terms. Ask whether your location participates before you visit.
Plan to dine in and order both an entrée and a beverage.
Which Thanksgiving pickups need advance sign-up?
The Tony Baroni Team says registered guests can pick up an XL free pie at its office on Tuesday, Nov. 24. Advance registration through its customer form is required, according to the Tony Baroni Team pie page.
Cardano Realtors says guests can pick up a free apple or pumpkin pie only on Nov. 24, 2026, from 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
at Abington Firehouse Hall. A reservation with a mobile number is required, according to the Cardano Realtors pie page. These are local pickup events, not restaurant service.
You must register first, then arrive at the stated place and time.
How do you avoid missing out?
Confirm the three details that control most pie offers: place, purchase, and reservation. Weekly slices depend on dine-in and location participation. Pickup pies depend on registration and a short pickup window.
Cardano Realtors limits pickup to Nov. 24 from 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
at Abington Firehouse Hall.
- Check that your Bakers Square location participates.
- Bring an appetite for an entrée plus a beverage for the slice offer.
- Register in advance for the Nov. 24 pickup you plan to attend.
- Save the pickup address and hours, and arrive on time.