How Much Should You Spend to Earn a Bonus Gift Card?

Match gift-card spending to firm gift plans, then check bonus dates and use limits before adding extra dollars.
Spend only the amount you already planned to give or use, starting at the lowest bonus level that fits that plan. Step up to $50 or $100 only if the added bonus is worth the added outlay and you can use it in time. A bonus gift card is a small store credit added when you buy a set amount in regular gift cards.
The purchased gift card lasts for years, but the bonus usually expires in weeks and carries tight use rules.
Verification note: Program terms and availability can change. This page was checked against linked sources on November 17, 2026.
Buy to your list, not to the bonus
Start with names, amounts, and where each person actually shops or eats. That list sets your spend, and the bonus is a side benefit. Do not add another recipient or raise a card amount only to reach the next bonus line.
Small thresholds help here because they track normal gifts. A $25 or $50 card often covers a family meal or a pie night. Larger jumps make sense only when you already intended to spend that much.
What do current thresholds pay?
According to Bakers Square, buyers get a $5 bonus for every $25 in gift cards bought Nov. 1-Dec. 31, 2026, redeemable in-store only Jan.
2-Mar. 31, 2027 with a one-bonus-per-table-per-visit limit (Bakers Square promo terms). That structure suits a small gift, since one $25 card earns one $5 bonus without extra spend.
According to Buffalo Wild Wings, buyers get a $10 bonus for every $50 in gift cards bought Nov. 10-Dec. 31, 2026, limit four per person, redeemable Nov.
27, 2026-Jan. 31, 2027 for food, products and non-alcoholic beverages only (Buffalo Wild Wings holiday terms). The cap matters, since buying $200 earns $40 and buying $250 earns no added bonus.
According to Lou Malnati's, buyers get a $10 certificate for $50 and a $25 certificate for $100 in gift cards bought Nov. 16-Dec. 31, 2026 (Lou Malnati's holiday bonus page).
The math favors the higher tier only for planned spend, since $100 pays 25% while $50 pays 20%.
Why does the fine print shrink the bonus?
Check when, where, and what the bonus buys before you pay. Many bonuses work in-store only, exclude alcohol and gift cards, and bar delivery or stacked discounts. A bonus you cannot use for your normal order has little value.
Also check who can use it and how often. A per-table or per-visit limit slows use for a large family or party. Short windows add pressure, since December purchases may expire by late January or February.
How do you avoid overspending for extra dollars?
Extra spend to chase a threshold often sits unused. According to a Bankrate survey of 2,373 adults, 43% held unused gift cards, vouchers or store credit averaging $244 per holder (Bankrate gift-card survey). That waste can erase a $5 or $10 bonus fast.
Use the December bonus on a January visit you already planned, not a new outing.
- Write the recipient and store for each card.
- Circle the bonus use-by date on your calendar.
- Skip the higher tier if it needs an extra trip.
- Give the purchased card promptly and keep the bonus for your own planned visit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I split one large gift card into smaller cards to earn more bonuses?
Follow the sponsor's per-person and per-purchase terms. Some offers pay per $25 or $50 block, while others cap total bonuses.
What should I do with a bonus that expires soon?
Use it for a small planned purchase, such as dessert, a side, or a non-alcoholic drink where allowed.