Holiday Bonus vs Gift Card: What Employers Typically Choose

Learn what employers give most, what workers prefer, and how holiday cash shows up on your paycheck.
Employers still choose cash bonuses more often than gift cards, but only about one-third follow that pattern in recent employer polling. In that manufacturing-employer poll, 34% gave cash, 12% gave gift cards and 21% gave no holiday bonus, according to MetalForming Magazine, manufacturing-employer holiday bonus poll. A holiday bonus here means extra year-end pay separate from regular wages.
Workers want cash by a wide margin, yet many do not receive it. In an October 2026 survey of 1,040 U.S. workers, 77% said they most want a cash bonus but only 34% typically receive one, according to the Zety report shared via PR Newswire, holiday gifting expectations release.
Verification note: Program terms and availability can change. This page was checked against linked sources on November 17, 2026.
How large is the want-versus-get gap?
The Zety report described the cash-bonus shortfall as the largest want-versus-receive gap among workplace gifts. Seventy-seven percent picked cash as their top want, while 34% said they typically get it. For readers, that gap matters for planning.
Cash can cover bills, travel, or savings, while other gifts have fixed uses. Expecting cash and receiving something else can change a holiday budget.
What do employer reports show besides cash?
The same MetalForming Magazine employer poll found gift cards far behind cash at 12%. Twenty-one percent gave no holiday bonus at all. That pattern means two common outcomes for workers.
You may receive a smaller flexible gift, or you may receive nothing tied to the holidays. Neither outcome reflects your performance alone.
Which reward motivates workers more?
In the Incentive Research Foundation July 2026 participant study, 93% rated cash bonuses very or extremely motivating, compared with 77% for gift cards. Merchandise was 40% and company swag was 22%. Both cash and gift cards motivate a large share of workers.
Cash holds a clear edge, while gift cards still rank well above merchandise and swag.
How are cash and gift cards taxed?
The IRS states in Publication 15-B for 2026 that cash and cash-equivalent fringe benefits, including gift cards, gift certificates and charge-card use, no matter how little, are never excludable as a de minimis benefit, IRS Publication 15-B guidance. That rule treats even a small card the same as cash wages. The IRS practical result affects your paycheck handling: Ask payroll how your holiday gift was coded before you compare your final pay stub to your W-2.
- employers must run holiday cash and gift cards of any amount through payroll for income-tax withholding
- the same amounts count for Social Security and Medicare and for W-2 Box 1 wages
- occasional small noncash gifts such as a ham or gift basket can qualify as tax-free de minimis