Cyber Monday Clothing Deals: How to Spot a Fake Markdown

Check today's clothing price against its prior 3-6 month low and the same SKU elsewhere before you buy.
A Cyber Monday clothing markdown is likely fake when the crossed-out "was" price was not actually charged regularly for a reasonably substantial period. Ignore the percent-off claim and compare today's price with the item's actual lowest price over the prior 3-6 months. A fake markdown is a crossed-out reference price set high to make the reduction look large.
Federal pricing guidance says that practice makes the advertised bargain false, according to the federal pricing guides hosted by Cornell LII.
Verification note: Program terms and availability can change. This page was checked against linked sources on November 16, 2026.
What makes a clothing markdown fake?
A legitimate "was" price is the actual, bona fide price offered regularly for a reasonably substantial period. An inflated price set only to enable a large reduction does not meet that test. Investigators have shown how this looks on the rack.
They highlighted a shirt marked 40 percent off $149 whose reference price looked lower behind the sticker, alongside a six-month track of 25 retailers finding "regular" prices were rarely actually charged, as reported by InvestigateTV citing nonprofit Consumers' Checkbook. A 2026 marketplace test of 20 products each on Amazon, eBay, Temu and Wayfair found seller-listed RRPs far above other sellers' prices. That matters because the UK Advertising Standards Authority says shoppers read RRP as the general market price, according to the Which? marketplace investigation.
Why does an inflated "was" price change what you pay?
A high reference price moves spending even when shoppers doubt it. Harvard researcher Donald Ngwe found each $1 increase in the posted original price raised what shoppers would pay by about 77 cents in a $40-handbag experiment using varied true and displayed original prices, according to the Harvard Business School report. The effect is practical on Cyber Monday.
A $120 "was" next to a $60 sale feels urgent, while the same $60 without a reference feels ordinary. The percent-off frames the decision around savings instead of value. That framing can push a quick buy in clothing, where sizes and colors sell out.
Treat excitement as a cue to check history, not as proof of a deal.
How can you test a Cyber Monday clothing price?
Start with the identical item, not a similar style. Check whether today's price beats the item's actual lowest price over the prior 3-6 months, plus compare the identical item at another retailer. If the Cyber Monday price is not below that prior low, it is not a markdown on your options.
Walk away or wait for a price-drop alert rather than trusting the crossed-out figure.
- Copy the exact product name, style number, and color.
- Search that exact item at one other retailer selling the same SKU.
- Look for the lowest price shown over the prior 3-6 months, not the average "was."
- Include shipping, returns, and size availability before calling it lower.
What can price-history tools show?
Free Amazon trackers CamelCamelCamel and Keepa record listing prices over time and chart highs, lows and averages. Users can set price-drop alerts rather than trusting the crossed-out "was" price. Those charts help for listings they cover.
They are strongest for an Amazon listing with a long history and clear size and color variants. They have clear limits for clothing. Major free history tools track Amazon listings well but do not establish in-store or boutique clothing prices, outlet-exclusive SKUs, or whether a former price lasted a "substantial period" under the federal test.
An outlet-exclusive style may never have a comparable market price.
What should you save and report?
Save the store name, item name and SKU, advertised "was" price, sale price, date, and a photo of the tag or listing. Keep the receipt and any ad showing the percent-off claim. Those details let you compare later and explain the issue clearly.
They also show whether the reference price reappears after Cyber Monday at the same level. Consumers who paid or see a likely fictitious clothing markdown can report the store, item, advertised "was" price and sale price to the FTC's fraud-reporting portal for use by law-enforcement investigators. Reporting takes a few minutes and preserves the exact numbers for review.